BRIGHT STAR - A movie review
New Zealander Jane Campion is one of the most intriguing women making movies. She's fought the male Hollywood bias to make independent films with fascinating topics. I don't love all of them -- like SWEETIE, which Russ liked and I found weird to the point of nauseating. But certainly THE PIANO and PORTRAIT OF A LADY (Campion does Henry James!).
It was fun to hear that her latest, BRIGHT STAR, was already such a hit at Cannes. It's on a topic interesting to me, mostly because it's an era that Tim Powers covers so well in his wonderfully researched fantasy books: the romantic poets. And it's told from the POV of the historical character most people consider a cipher, or a rampant siren, in the life of the much-more-famous John Keats.
There's a lot to like in BRIGHT STAR, and one big thing to love. The big thing to love: it's about a relationship that ends, one would think, with the death by tuberculosis of Keats, but Campion doesn't write towards that. I've gotten so tired of the movies lately who make a major character's long-expected death the big climax of the movie. That's lazy, built-in melodrama. But Campion has the characters last parting be the main climax, with all its pain and confusion, and bittersweet pretending of a future. And she has the actual announcement of Keats' death create a sort of shift in the relationship and respect of the two other major characters.
The period feels wonderfully real; the muddy back doors into the clotheslines, the rustic kitchens where people hang out when they're relaxing and the parlour is too prim. The dark, cold, awful, rented rooms people with little to no money must live in. What a huge burst of arterial blood coughed up onto sheets looks like. The compotes and other dishes of the day, especially on holidays. Fanny's costumes are both part of her characterization and an indication of the few channels for creativity allowed to a woman in that culture. Oh, they were gorgeous! Unusual and sometimes too idiosyncratic, which, yeah, a woman trying to carve her own niche would do.
Abby Cornish is wonderful as Fanny Brawne. She has to be smart and smart-aleck, pretty enough to have a dozen suitors. Descriptions of the historical person vary, but she was a fashionista for her time, designs and productions of her own hand, and she was considered a popular girl. By her own admission she did not enjoy or understand poetry, which was such a boys' club anyway, but she came to admire and understand it from her relationship with Keats. Cornish is not perfect; sometimes her stiff and clumsy way of moving made me think "21st century girl in a corset." She did too much tucking back of her severe hairdo's, which is a modern girl thing too. But she played the part with no makeup, and she was intelligent and plausibly emotional.
Ben Whishaw is a wonderful actor who is homelier than he needs to be. He's only mid-20's, but even in his teenage years looked like a gnome in making. He's craggy already, with his heavy Neanderthal brow, and he never gets to shave completely in this part. He's been convincing as the murderous savant peasant in PARFUME, then fragile and sad as Sebastian in BRIDESHEAD REVISITED.
He plays a poet just fine because he's such a smart guy (and, if his personal interviews are a clue, extremely soft spoken and probably gay), but is less convincing to me as the potential lover of the robust Cornish. He's so thin and short that once the dramatic challenge of his health arises, he plays a TB patient very convincingly, though. He's famous for an alternate Hamlet he did on the London stage while still only 19-20 years old, so his voice is wonderful for reciting Keats poetry.
In fact, the movie is worth the price of admission to hear both Whishaw and Cornish speak several stanzas of Keats verse; you don't think recitations could take your breath away, but Campion sets up every quoting as something emotion and special. The final credits are done over Whishaw speaking "Ode to a Nightingale" and what you might remember as purple prose from high school English is wonderful.
Paul Schneider as Charles Brown, Keats' friend and jealous protector, is amazing. Hate the guy, but have to empathize with him too. And I defy you to hear his good Scottish brogue and recall that he was born and bred in South Carolina! Kerry Fox as Fanny's quiet, mostly supportive mother really grounds the story, as does Thomas Sangster as Fanny's watchful teenage brother. And her little sister Toots is given several touching moments, and familiar sisterly fighting moments, that little round-eyed, red-haired Edie Martin makes indelible.
It was fun to hear that her latest, BRIGHT STAR, was already such a hit at Cannes. It's on a topic interesting to me, mostly because it's an era that Tim Powers covers so well in his wonderfully researched fantasy books: the romantic poets. And it's told from the POV of the historical character most people consider a cipher, or a rampant siren, in the life of the much-more-famous John Keats.
There's a lot to like in BRIGHT STAR, and one big thing to love. The big thing to love: it's about a relationship that ends, one would think, with the death by tuberculosis of Keats, but Campion doesn't write towards that. I've gotten so tired of the movies lately who make a major character's long-expected death the big climax of the movie. That's lazy, built-in melodrama. But Campion has the characters last parting be the main climax, with all its pain and confusion, and bittersweet pretending of a future. And she has the actual announcement of Keats' death create a sort of shift in the relationship and respect of the two other major characters.
The period feels wonderfully real; the muddy back doors into the clotheslines, the rustic kitchens where people hang out when they're relaxing and the parlour is too prim. The dark, cold, awful, rented rooms people with little to no money must live in. What a huge burst of arterial blood coughed up onto sheets looks like. The compotes and other dishes of the day, especially on holidays. Fanny's costumes are both part of her characterization and an indication of the few channels for creativity allowed to a woman in that culture. Oh, they were gorgeous! Unusual and sometimes too idiosyncratic, which, yeah, a woman trying to carve her own niche would do.
Abby Cornish is wonderful as Fanny Brawne. She has to be smart and smart-aleck, pretty enough to have a dozen suitors. Descriptions of the historical person vary, but she was a fashionista for her time, designs and productions of her own hand, and she was considered a popular girl. By her own admission she did not enjoy or understand poetry, which was such a boys' club anyway, but she came to admire and understand it from her relationship with Keats. Cornish is not perfect; sometimes her stiff and clumsy way of moving made me think "21st century girl in a corset." She did too much tucking back of her severe hairdo's, which is a modern girl thing too. But she played the part with no makeup, and she was intelligent and plausibly emotional.
Ben Whishaw is a wonderful actor who is homelier than he needs to be. He's only mid-20's, but even in his teenage years looked like a gnome in making. He's craggy already, with his heavy Neanderthal brow, and he never gets to shave completely in this part. He's been convincing as the murderous savant peasant in PARFUME, then fragile and sad as Sebastian in BRIDESHEAD REVISITED.
He plays a poet just fine because he's such a smart guy (and, if his personal interviews are a clue, extremely soft spoken and probably gay), but is less convincing to me as the potential lover of the robust Cornish. He's so thin and short that once the dramatic challenge of his health arises, he plays a TB patient very convincingly, though. He's famous for an alternate Hamlet he did on the London stage while still only 19-20 years old, so his voice is wonderful for reciting Keats poetry.
In fact, the movie is worth the price of admission to hear both Whishaw and Cornish speak several stanzas of Keats verse; you don't think recitations could take your breath away, but Campion sets up every quoting as something emotion and special. The final credits are done over Whishaw speaking "Ode to a Nightingale" and what you might remember as purple prose from high school English is wonderful.
Paul Schneider as Charles Brown, Keats' friend and jealous protector, is amazing. Hate the guy, but have to empathize with him too. And I defy you to hear his good Scottish brogue and recall that he was born and bred in South Carolina! Kerry Fox as Fanny's quiet, mostly supportive mother really grounds the story, as does Thomas Sangster as Fanny's watchful teenage brother. And her little sister Toots is given several touching moments, and familiar sisterly fighting moments, that little round-eyed, red-haired Edie Martin makes indelible.
